Further comments posted on IndianMuslims.in blogsite

Further comments posted on IndianMuslims.in blogsite





Wednesday, June 04, 2008


Amit wrote:


“GM, please take note: Your views on Brahmins are a very racist GENERALIZATION! Generalizations are odious. I would go as far as to say that if India was indeed governed (not ruled) by Brahmins (like Nehru, Indira etc.), Thank God! Why shouldn’t the Brahmins govern? They’re by & large the more educated class in the country. If they’re communal, they have the confidence to express it. You have a choice; don’t vote for them!”


My views on Brahmins, even if some kind of alleged racist generalisation, pale in comparison to the whole 2000 year record of racism perpetrated by the Brahmins, cleverly wrapped in Manu’s caste spin doctoring of the supposed birth of Brahmins from the head of the Gods. By the far the vast majority of the so-called Hindus of degraded to lower castes by Manu’s dictates, hold the Brahmins responsible in concocting such myths and exploiting it to subjugate the victims. The kind of apartheid that had been imposed by the Brahmins on the lower caste, that prohibits them to even live in Brahmin villages, pass through their roads, drink from their wells, that had lasted for thousands of years, is more sinister and sadist than the apartheid practiced by the White supremacists of South Africa.


The 3% Brahmins should not govern or rule in a democratic country, as they do not have the number. Their so-called slight of hand majority, is a big fraud on gullible voters. Their behind the scene machinations to use their strategic dominance in bureaucracy to favour their own caste brethrens, cannot be appreciated or tolerated by the rest of the 97 percent of the population and a reaction is bound to surface. A storm is long a coming.


By the responses that I observe on this site to the grievances against Brahmins, it seems Brahmins are too absorbed in their own ghetto world; completely unaware of the storm gathering and the ripening of crop of deep disenchantment and anger that they have been sowing by their insensitive and relentless onslaught on the just demands of the rest of Indian people.


Amit has every right to thank God, that Brahmins had governed India; after all the Brahmin hegemony has served their own kind to the utmost. However, as far as Indian state has discriminated and deliberately resorted to ‘cleanse’ the system of the Malechas, to enjoy their monopoly power, through means fair and foul, those others who are victims of their overzealous and undeserved overlordship over others in a democratic set-up, have every right to put out their cases, their grievances and take all measures at their command, to expose the viciousness of the Brahminical conspiracies and call for collective measures to curb their excesses.


Amit feels that since they have confidence to be communal, they have a right to be communal and right to express it. Have gun will shoot.


By the same criteria, others if they acquire confidence, they too should and would express themselves and fight the communalism that Brahmins have unleashed on a supposedly secular nation.


As for the choices available to non-Brahmins, Amit need not be so gracious as to suggest the Marie Antoinette solution — ‘go eat the cake, if you do not get bread’. Amit should keep an eye on history, how revolutions start with such trigger situations.


I will concede one point about generalisation. On a personal level, Brahmins are best of friends and worst of enemies. It takes all to make a community. I salute those who are confident and generous enough to concede and condemn the excesses heaped by their kind on the others. They are not the focus of my grievances, as long as they upheld truth and justice and are ready to make amends.


Ghulam Muhammed, Mumbai






Tags: , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: